We are live on ! Find out more

Small Cap
Property & Casualty Insurance
Stocks Ranked by
Market Capitalization

Name Market cap Price Price
change %
HMN icon
1
Horace Mann Educators
HMN
$1.86B
$1.86B $46 1.05%
HGTY icon
2
Hagerty
HGTY
$1.76B
$1.76B $15.64 1.94%
KMPR icon
3
Kemper
KMPR
$1.71B
$1.71B $29.05 0.62%
SAFT icon
4
Safety Insurance
SAFT
$1.53B
$1.53B $104.23 0.17%
UFCS icon
5
United Fire Group
UFCS
$1.47B
$1.47B $57.02 0.97%
STC icon
6
Stewart Information Services
STC
$1.33B
$1.33B $43.47 1.19%
UVE icon
7
Universal Insurance Holdings
UVE
$1.33B
$1.33B $47.61 0.54%
TRUP icon
8
Trupanion
TRUP
$1.25B
$1.25B $28.59 3.96%
BOW icon
9
Bowhead Specialty Holdings
BOW
$1.13B
$1.13B $34.29 0.44%
ASIC icon
10
Ategrity Specialty Insurance
ASIC
$1.13B
$1.13B $23.54 1.59%
HRTG icon
11
Heritage Insurance Holdings
HRTG
$1.09B
$1.09B $36.51 1.59%
HIPO icon
12
Hippo Holdings
HIPO
$1.01B
$1.01B $38.20 0.91%
OIG
13
Orion180 Insurance Group Inc. Class A common stock
OIG
$904M
$904M $9.13 0.11%
DGICB icon
14
Donegal Group Class B
DGICB
$895M
$895M $24.10 0%
ROOT icon
15
Root
ROOT
$806M
$806M $52.05 0.42%
DGICA icon
16
Donegal Group Class A
DGICA
$689M
$689M $18.57 1.9%
AII icon
17
American Integrity Insurance
AII
$569M
$569M $29.03 1.66%
ACIC icon
18
American Coastal Insurance
ACIC
$519M
$519M $10.98 1.35%
GBLI icon
19
Global Indemnity Group
GBLI
$354M
$354M $24.18 5.03%
NODK icon
20
NI Holdings
NODK
$302M
$302M $14.79 0.14%
KINS icon
21
Kingstone Companies
KINS
$283M
$283M $19.53 2.2%

Small Cap Property & Casualty Insurance Stocks at a Glance

Property and casualty insurers cover property, auto, liability, and catastrophe risks. Underwriting profit — premiums minus claims and costs — plus investment income on float drives returns, with pricing moving in hard and soft market cycles shaped by catastrophe losses.

There are 21 small cap Property & Casualty Insurance stocks — companies in the Property & Casualty Insurance industry with a market cap between $250M and $2B — worth a combined $21.9B.

The largest by market cap are Horace Mann Educators (HMN) at $1.86B, Hagerty (HGTY) at $1.76B and Kemper (KMPR) at $1.71B.

Among institutional investors, Bowhead Specialty Holdings (BOW) drew the most net new fund positions in Q2 2026: 39 funds opened new positions, taking total fund holders up 22 (14%) quarter-over-quarter.

Market caps and prices updated daily; fund activity based on aggregated SEC 13F filings for Q2 2026.